Detailed checklist and error tracking help assess surgeon skill

Free Consultation713-781-5200

  • SuperLawyers General
  • MMDAF logo
  • Million dollar advocates badge 1 1
  • abota bdg
  • 233 2331196 top 40 under national trial lawyers top 100
  • logo av
  • whos who
Legally reviewed by:
Steven R. Davis and John A. Davis, Jr.
August 4, 2023

When a Houston resident needs to have surgery it can be a stressful situation. All surgeries carry risk but an error caused by a surgeon may be the result of negligence. The training a surgeon receives is important in making sure they don’t make negligent surgical errors.
A study recently done by Johns Hopkins shows that having checklists of steps that need to be completed and tracking errors in surgeons who are in training can lead to better quality surgeons. A checklist is a good way to test if a surgical resident has good technical skills. The study used the Objective Structured Assessment of Technical Skills (OSATS) checklist. The surgical residents received a point for successfully completing each step in order and a zero if they went out of order or made a mistake. They also used a Global Rating Scale that provides feedback on whether they used surgical instruments correctly, if they had a broad understanding of the procedure they are performing, and other holistic areas. The third evaluation procedure was a simple pass-fail based on whether they performed an egregious error, such as severing a nerve or blood vessel.
The training a surgeon receives is critical in making sure they are able to offer their patients high-quality, expert care. Patients who are victims of an unexpected surgical error, such as organ damage, bowel injury, having surgical equipment left inside of them, and other serious mistakes can feel angry and disappointed in their surgeon. IF a family believes their loved one was the victim of a surgical error, they may want to speak with a legal professional skilled in medical malpractice.
Victims of surgical errors can suffer from years of pain and suffering and even death. It is important that surgeons receive the best training possible but if they make a mistake, that they are held responsible.
Source:, “Beyond checklists, a better way to assess surgical skill“, July 5, 2016

John A. Davis, Jr.


John A. Davis, Jr. and Steven R. Davis

August 4 2023

Steven R. Davis and John A. Davis, Jr. are experienced attorneys at Davis & Davis, a law firm that specializes in medical malpractice cases in Texas. With a deep commitment to justice that guides their ethical approach, Davis and Davis have dedicated their careers to helping victims of medical negligence. They and their team continue to advocate for clients, despite the challenges posed by Texas's cap on recoverable damages in malpractice lawsuits. Davis & Davis pride themselves on their extensive experience in the field and their readiness to meet clients across the United States.

✓ Fact Checked