When a delivery runs into complications, parents often have one immediate task: getting answers about what happened. Some birth injuries are unavoidable, and some can be caused by negligent care from a doctor or medical staff. Telling the two apart usually requires a careful look at the medical records and the decisions made during labor.
This post first ran in October 2013. It described a medical malpractice trial reported by AL.com that September, in which parents in Alabama sued the obstetrician who delivered their daughter. We have updated it to date the story clearly, to describe it as a dispute that was being tried rather than a proven case, and to explain what families in Texas can ask after a difficult delivery. We have not confirmed how the case was resolved, so this post does not report an outcome.
What the 2013 Trial Was About
According to the AL.com report, the parents alleged that they had not been told their baby was expected to be large, that the baby’s shoulders became stuck during delivery, and that a vacuum device was used before the doctor performed an emergency cesarean section. The parents said their daughter was left with a permanent brachial plexus injury affecting one arm. The obstetrician disputed the claim, arguing through her defense that her care did not cause the injury and that her actions saved the baby’s life.
Those were the competing positions at the start of a trial. They were allegations and defenses, not findings, and a jury or court decides which account the evidence supports. We describe the story here only because it raises questions that many families face after a delivery that ends in an arm or shoulder injury.
Shoulder Dystocia, Large Babies, and Brachial Plexus Injuries
Shoulder dystocia happens when a baby’s head has delivered but a shoulder becomes caught behind the mother’s pelvic bone. It is an obstetric emergency, and the delivery team has a short window to free the shoulder using recognized maneuvers. Excessive force or the wrong technique can stretch or tear the nerves that run from the neck to the arm, called the brachial plexus. Some of these injuries heal over months, while others leave lasting weakness, as our page on brachial plexus palsy explains.
A larger than average baby, known as fetal macrosomia, is one of the recognized risk factors for shoulder dystocia, along with maternal diabetes and a prior shoulder dystocia. Estimating a baby’s weight before birth is imprecise, even with ultrasound. The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists’ 2020 practice bulletin on macrosomia says a planned cesarean delivery may be considered when the estimated fetal weight is at least 5,000 grams in a mother without diabetes, or at least 4,500 grams in a mother with diabetes. Below those levels, the decision depends on the full clinical picture.
Questions Families Can Ask After a Difficult Delivery
Whether a birth injury was preventable usually turns on what the care team knew, when they knew it, and what they did in response. Questions that often matter include whether risk factors such as diabetes or a large estimated weight were identified during prenatal care, and whether the delivery plan was discussed with the mother. Families also ask whether shoulder dystocia was recognized promptly and managed with accepted maneuvers, whether a vacuum or forceps was used and why, and how the delivery was documented in the record.
No single answer proves negligence. A brachial plexus injury can occur even when the delivery is handled well, and Texas law requires a qualified medical expert to explain whether the care fell below the accepted standard and whether that caused the injury.
Birth Injury Claims in Texas
In Texas, a claim against a doctor or hospital for a birth injury is a health care liability claim under Chapter 74 of the Civil Practice and Remedies Code. These claims carry strict requirements, including written notice before suit and an expert report served within 120 days after each defendant files an answer. Deadlines for a child’s own claim follow special rules: under Section 74.251, a child injured before age 12 generally has until their 14th birthday to file, while the parents’ own claims, such as for medical expenses, generally follow the standard two-year limit.
If a claim succeeds, damages may include past and future medical care, therapy, and other costs tied to the injury. Every case is different, and no result can be promised. If your child suffered an arm or shoulder injury at birth and you have questions about the care, contact Davis & Davis to talk with our birth injury attorneys.
Frequently Asked Questions About Shoulder Dystocia Birth Injuries
Is every brachial plexus injury at birth caused by malpractice?
No. A brachial plexus injury can happen even when a delivery is managed appropriately. A malpractice claim requires showing that the care fell below the accepted standard, for example by missing known risk factors or using excessive force during a shoulder dystocia, and that this departure caused the injury. A qualified medical expert must review the records to answer those questions.
Should a doctor perform a C-section if the baby is expected to be large?
Not automatically. Guidance from the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists says a planned cesarean may be considered when the estimated fetal weight is at least 5,000 grams in a mother without diabetes or at least 4,500 grams in a mother with diabetes. Because weight estimates before birth are imprecise, the decision depends on the mother’s history, the estimated size, and a discussion of risks and options.
What records help show what happened during a shoulder dystocia delivery?
Useful records include prenatal notes and ultrasound reports, glucose testing results, the labor and delivery record, fetal monitoring strips, the delivery note describing any maneuvers used and how long the shoulder was stuck, and the newborn’s records. Requesting the complete records early helps an attorney and a medical expert reconstruct the timeline.
How long do we have to file a birth injury claim in Texas?
Under Section 74.251 of the Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code, a child injured before age 12 generally has until their 14th birthday to bring their own claim, subject to a 10-year outer limit. The parents’ own claims, such as for the child’s medical expenses, generally must be filed within two years, and Texas does not apply a general discovery rule. An attorney can confirm the deadlines that apply to your family.
Source: AL.com, “Trial begins for Madison obstetrician sued for malpractice, defense argues she saved baby’s life,” Brian Lawson, Sept. 24, 2013

